Environmental Laboratory

How Does Smart Home Automation Affect the Environment?

Apr 29 2018 Read 8576 Times

The practice of smart home automation – or the interconnectivity of household appliances, lighting, heating and security measures through the internet – is becoming more and more popular in the UK and abroad. One of the purported selling points of such a system is the beneficial effects it has on the environment (and on bills) by optimising the use of energy and flattening peak consumption rates.

While previous studies have appeared to support such a hypothesis, a new paper from the University of Oulu in Finland suggests this may not be the case. By using a life-cycle assessment (LCA) method of analysis, the researchers concluded that the consumption of energy of the smart devices outweighs the benefits that they offer over a five-year period. The findings cast aspersions on the efficacy of smart home automation as a viable environmental tool.

What is smart home automation?

Smart home automation is the practice of using internet-enabled devices to remotely and automatically control appliances, lighting fixtures, heating systems and security measures in and around your home. For example, you could use your phone to turn on the oven just as you’re leaving work so that dinner is ready by the time you arrive home, or synchronise your heating with weather forecasts to make sure your house is never unduly cold.

In practice, it sounds like the stuff of science-fiction and proponents of the technology have capitalised upon a growing market for environmental gadgetry by promising it can reduce electricity consumption through only turning on lights, heating and appliances when they are really needed. Previous studies on the subject (such as the 2014 paper from Jean-Nicolas Louis) have tended to agree that automation can reduce energy consumption and carbon emissions, with Louis arguing in the linked study that a smart home can bring down CO2 emissions by 13%.

The other side of the coin

The new study, also undertaken by Louis and published in the journal Science Direct, seeks to provide further clarity on the subject by taking into account the electricity consumption of the smart plugs themselves. Assuming that the home energy management system (HEMS) would have a lifespan of five years, the team found that smart meters would be capable of paying for themselves (in terms of energy consumption) within 3.5 months of a year, giving 8.5 months of benefits. They would also give a single month of benefits with regards to carbon emissions every year.

However, the smart plugs were far more energy intensive in their consumption, using over four times the amount that the meters did. In fact, they did not prove themselves to be worth the investment either from an energy consumption or carbon emissions standpoint over the five-year period and suffered a deficit of 1.6 years. These findings lend weight to the idea that smart devices may actually contribute to global warming rather than prevent it, and call for the industry to place greater emphasis on the amount of electricity consumed by smart devices when weighing up their pros and cons.

Read comments0

Do you like or dislike what you have read? Why not post a comment to tell others / the manufacturer and our Editor what you think. To leave comments please complete the form below. Providing the content is approved, your comment will be on screen in less than 24 hours. Leaving comments on product information and articles can assist with future editorial and article content. Post questions, thoughts or simply whether you like the content.

Digital Edition

International Environmental Technology June 2018

June 2018

In This Edition Business News - Servomex appoints Trevor Sands as company president - DURAG Group acquire AP2E - A love of fl y-fi shing leads to 20 years of volunteerism at Restek Gas D...

View all digital editions


DXC 2018

Aug 06 2018 Westminster, CO, USA

IBS 2018

Aug 12 2018 Montreal, Canada

DioXin 2018

Aug 26 2018 Krakow, Poland

World Water Week 2018

Aug 26 2018 Stockholm, Sweden

View all events