Gas Detection

Metrological calibration of mercury gas generators

Feb 21 2024

Author: Iris de Krom on behalf of VSL Dutch Metrology Institute

Free to read

Articles are free to download. Unlock the article to be shown more content, graphs and images.

Mercury (Hg) is ubiquitously present in the atmosphere, thus monitoring of the Hg concentrations in emission sources and the atmosphere has become a global requirement in recent years. Industrial sites are required to implement adequate monitoring equipment (e.g., analysers and gas generators) and report their emissions to relevant authorities. To obtain accurate and reliable measurement results the appropriate calibration of monitoring equipment is required. Furthermore, documentary standards set requirements for the calibration and also validation and quality control of CEMs.
EN 14181:2014 sets requirements for the quality assurance of automated measuring systems. There are requirements for the calibration and validation and for quality control. Specific guidance for Hg measurement is given in EN 14884:2022 where different test require the use of Hg gas generators, such as the zero and span checks, linearity test, response time and converter efficiency. For the first 3 experiments both elemental mercury (Hg0) and oxidised mercury (HgII) gas generators can be used for the last one only HgII gas generators. According to these documentary standards Hg CEMs are calibrated using Hg gas generators. But how are Hg gas generator calibrated?
For decades gaseous Hg concentration measurements have been calibrated based on Hg vapour pressure equations (e.g., the Dumarey or the Huber equation). Currently these equations differ from each other by more than 7 % at 20 °C and this discrepancy is of great concern as it hampers comparable and reliable measurement results for Hg concentrations in the atmosphere and emissions sources. In the past decade considerable effort has been put into the development of certified reference standards and calibration methods for Hg concentrations traceable to the International System of Units (SI) to ensure comparable and reliable Hg measurement results.
Notwithstanding these efforts, there are no standardised procedures that ensure the dissemination of the SI traceable calibration methods from certified reference standards via Hg gas generators to monitoring equipment used for emission and atmospheric monitoring. Scientifically and metrologically sound calibration protocols, used to assess the performance of Hg gas generators in the form of formally accepted documentary standards, are of fundamental importance to guarantee the accuracy and comparability of the Hg measurement results in gas emission sources and in the atmosphere in Europe and globally.
Within the EMPIR (European Metrology Programme for Innovation and Research) SI-Hg project (Metrology for traceable protocols for elemental and oxidised mercury concentrations - 19NRM03 www.SI-Hg.eu) such metrologically sound calibration protocols were developed and validated.
The protocols specify procedures for establishing traceability to the SI for the quantitative output of Hg gas generators that are employed in regulatory applications for Hg monitoring or testing. It includes methods to determine the output of a Hg gas generator by comparison with a reference standard and to calculate the Hg concentration and the corresponding uncertainty generated by a candidate generator in relation to the known uncertainty of the reference standard. The Hg concentration in a gas mixture prepared with a candidate generator is compared with a Hg concentration prepared with a metrologically traceable reference standard to calibrate the output of a candidate generator. For the comparison both gas mixtures, from the candidate generator and reference standards are directed to a Hg analyser.
By performing calibrations according to the protocol a traceability chain starting from a metrologically certified reference standards can be established by comparison of a candidate generator to the primary standard or reference standard according to the measurement procedure described in the protocol. After calibration the candidate generator receives an SI traceable certificate and can be used as a reference generator for calibration of other candidate generators, and so forth (Figure 1). This way a chain of calibrations is obtained from the primary standard to gas generators used every day for monitoring of Hg concentrations in emission sources and in the atmosphere.
The traceability chain for Hg0 concentrations is straightforward as there are primary gas standards available at National Metrology Institutes. However, such gas standards do not exist for HgII and traceability to the SI is established using the Hg0 standards. Furthermore, in online monitoring, HgII needs to be converted to Hg0, since online analysers are only capable of measuring total Hg. To ensure SI traceable measurement results for HgII concentrations can be obtained a method was developed to determine the converter efficiency of Hg analysers. Furthermore, the best storage conditions and the stability for HgCl2 solutions and HgCl2 salts were determined. For the generation of HgII gas mixtures HgCl2 solutions are used in liquid evaporative Hg gas generators. The results obtained were incorporated in the calibration protocol developed for HgII gas generators.  
To determine if the developed calibration protocols are fit for purpose validation measurements were performed by evaluating Hg gas generators available on the market. During the performance evaluation candidate generators were calibrated according to the protocols and based on the measurement data characteristics were determined, e.g., the stabilisation period, short-term drift, precision, i.e., reproducibility and repeatability of the concentration generated, linearity, bias, sensitivity to sample gas pressure, sensitivity to surrounding temperature and sensitivity to electrical voltage. All Hg gas generators could be tested according to the calibration protocols developed within the project. The results obtained with the different Hg gas generators clearly show the importance of a metrological calibration (Figure 2).
The SI-Hg project successfully developed calibration protocols for Hg0 and HgII gas generators. Validation of the protocols was obtained through the performance evaluation of Hg gas generators available on the market. Based on the results calibration protocols, validation reports and good practice guides were written. These documents are available online (www.SI-Hg.eu and/or Search Metrology for traceable protocols for elemental and oxidised mercury concentrations (zenodo.org)). The documents have been handed over to CEN/TC 264 “Air Quality” WG8 “Measurement of Total Mercury Emissions”. This standardisation committee will work on the conversion of the protocols into written documentary standards. Once, the documentary standards are in place they will replace other non-comparable references used in industry to calibrate Hg gas generators and ensure SI traceable measurement results for Hg concentrations in emission sources and the atmosphere. This is essential to underpin global efforts to control and reduce the concentration of Hg in the environment, comply with legislation and protect human health.
This project (19NRM03 SI-Hg) has received funding from the EMPIR programme co-financed by the Participating States and from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme.
Acknowledgments go to the SI-Hg project consortium, VSL, JSI, LGC Limited, VTT, CNR, Lumex Analytical GmbH, P. S. Analytical Limited and TÜV Rheinland Energy GmbH.
                                                                       

 

 

Free to read

Articles are free to download. Please login to read this article or create an account.


Digital Edition

IET 34.2 March 2024

April 2024

Gas Detection - Biogas batch fermentation system for laboratory use with automatic gas analysis in real time Water/Wastewater - Upcycling sensors for sustainable nature management - Prist...

View all digital editions

Events

Lab Indonesia

Apr 24 2024 Jakarta, Indonesia

IFAT Brasil

Apr 24 2024 Sao Paulo, Brasil

Ozwater'23

Apr 30 2024 Melbourne, Australia

The Safety & Health Event

Apr 30 2024 Birmingham, UK

ENVEX 2024

May 03 2024 Seoul, South Korea

View all events